Hanging Chads

The big question was, how do I keep the kids engaged with the reading choice and not plunge into squabbling over every title?

When I first started my book discussion Novel Thoughts (oh! those many years ago), I just couldn’t imagine spending time every month debating with the kids about what book we should read next.  It would be self indulgent to suggest only books that I liked or thought were good.  Meanwhile, if I left it solely up to the kids they could only offer suggestions of titles they have already read.  (I shudder to imagine how many times we would have “discussed” Harry Potter.)

I no long remember the eureka moment, but trust me, it was a stroke of genius.

Use democracy, dear Watson!  Every four months I create a ballot and they vote.  I get to decide what’s on the ballot – they decide what we read.  Perfect!

Except now, after more than seven years, I dread this part of the process.  I spend the better part of a day (or two) configuring a new ballot.

Here’s how it works:  each ballot is divided into four genre categories.  These change from ballot to ballot.  This time the categories are Historical Fiction, Mystery, Contemporary, and Science Fiction.  For each genre I include three titles: one with a female narrator, one a male, and then a novel that includes a mixed group of protagonists.  Each contending title includes a summary straight from our online catalog.

The kids read the summaries and vote on one title from each of the genres.

Easier said then done.  While the premise is fairly simple, finding three science fiction titles, for example, with a range of narrators that would make for good discussions can be darn right difficult.  And there’s another element I haven’t mentioned yet – page count.

In order to have a decent discussion the majority of the participants need to be able to finish the book.  And let’s face it, schoolwork needs to come first, so the book cannot be overwhelmingly long.  Publishers just don’t seem to consider this.  Nearly every science fiction title that seemed to fit all the other perimeters ended up being well over 300 pages!  I’m not alone in this struggle; see blogger Jonathan Hunt”s rant Is This Absolutely Necessary  over at the School Library Journal.

After seven years the Novel Thoughts group has discussed 88 titles!  Finding new and fresh titles, fewer than 300 pages, with enough copies to borrow from area libraries; across a range of gender interests is really a remarkable challenge.  I’m relieved that say that it only took me about 4 hours to accomplish today.  I can relax for another four months.

And the real beauty of the whole thing – no discussion!  It’s a silent ballot, a drumroll revelation and then sweet acceptance of the decision.


One response to “Hanging Chads

  1. Do you choose door #1, door #2 or door #3 ? Always good to keep it simple.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s